381 replies to this topic

[Lauren]

Yes Syesha or Kristi tonight.. David A 100% how I feel and I thought I read somewhere that he had some kind of deal already prior to coming to Idol. I wonder if he isn't another planted contestant. I think he is a good singer but I don't think he is "Idol" actually I don't see any "Idol" type up there maybe David Cook but he needs to reign in his "big ego"...

They use planted contestants?? Like who?? Just curious....

[stacycam]

Here's the info about the "plants." Be careful on the website because they have already posted who goes home. Now I know.

Anyway, here's the link: http://www.voteforth...dol7contestants

[Darthvader]

Here's the info about the "plants." Be careful on the website because they have already posted who goes home. Now I know.

Anyway, here's the link: http://www.voteforth...dol7contestants

Horrible results show, I can't believe the Aussie got the boot. The 2 girls were WAY worse. I don't think he could have won the whole thing but it's too early for him to go. And I like the way Seacrest lead him on about last season and nobody going home then he says "too bad you're out." I would have punched that little twit.

[EDH Jen]

Horrible results show, I can't believe the Aussie got the boot. The 2 girls were WAY worse. I don't think he could have won the whole thing but it's too early for him to go. And I like the way Seacrest lead him on about last season and nobody going home then he says "too bad you're out." I would have punched that little twit.

One of the few times we agree, Darth.
Syesha and Carly need to go home. I thought M.J. did a great job on 'Dream On' - and I'm a huge fan of all post-drug-free Aerosmith - and he'd done well before. Christy Lee is doing really well on the 'country thang', which seems to be the big money maker, post-idol, so good for her in her song choice.
I honestly thought Jason Castro would go - I'm a big Jack Johnson fan from way back, and I dig his thing, but I was feeling like the judges and voting audiences weren't. But what do I know...

[stacycam]

I haven't watched the results yet, but we're going to go watch it now. I think Jason Castro has the ladies voting for him. He's got a nice mellow sound, great smile, and gorgeous eyes.

It sounds like Ryan really screws over MJ. I'm going to go watch.........

[normajean]

so glad michael johns got the adios. never did like him, i know everyone else did, but not me. too arrogant for my taste, had the attitude of ima win this whole thing, like he expected to win, oops.

now he's just michael GONES.........dream on.......bye bye

[Steve Heard]

Christy Lee is doing really well on the 'country thang', which seems to be the big money maker, post-idol, so good for her in her song choice.

According to Vote for the Worst, there's a good reason for that. Even though they show her livng on a farm and feedin' horses, and Randy Jackson tells her, "You could be a country star" as if she's a newbie, she was signed to Arista Nashville in 2001.

Also, Archuleta won starsearch at 12 and had a record deal.

We already know that Carly had CD released under her maiden name (Hennessy).

Michael Johns has fronted 2 bands with record deals.

Syesha was on a TV show.

Jason Castro was on Cheyenne on MTV.

Brooke toured around the country opening for Phil Vassar.

These kids are pros.

The show should be called, 'Second Chance Idol'

[MSgt]

According to Vote for the Worst, there's a good reason for that. Even though they show her livng on a farm and feedin' horses, and Randy Jackson tells her, "You could be a country star" as if she's a newbie, she was signed to Arista Nashville in 2001.

Also, Archuleta won starsearch at 12 and had a record deal.
We already know that Carly had CD released under her maiden name (Hennessy).
Michael Johns has fronted 2 bands with record deals.
Syesha was on a TV show.
Jason Castro was on Cheyenne on MTV.
Brooke toured around the country opening for Phil Vassar.
These kids are pros.
The show should be called, 'Second Chance Idol'

very disapointing news. I didn't know any of this. I knew David Archeta's little boy act was an act but I couldn't prove it.

[Dave Burrell]

I think Jason Castro will be heading back to college to further cultivate his hydroponic closet pot garden.

yeah me thinks he probably has a good sized garden growing

[Dave Burrell]

One of the few times we agree, Darth.
Syesha and Carly need to go home. I thought M.J. did a great job on 'Dream On' - and I'm a huge fan of all post-drug-free Aerosmith - and he'd done well before. Christy Lee is doing really well on the 'country thang', which seems to be the big money maker, post-idol, so good for her in her song choice.
I honestly thought Jason Castro would go - I'm a big Jack Johnson fan from way back, and I dig his thing, but I was feeling like the judges and voting audiences weren't. But what do I know...

dang I missed last nights show and was very surprised to hear that Michael got the boot... I agree Sayesha or Carly or Kristy Lee should be gone before him. On Jason, I like him but he's always only singing songs that fit his niche, he doesn't seem to be able to branch out beyond the acoustic guitar folk sound

[Dave Burrell]

These kids are pros.

The show should be called, 'Second Chance Idol'

the second chance season....

[cw68]

So David Cook is the only non-experienced dude in there now? Or am I forgetting someone else?

[camay2327]

So how many of you people actually vote??? I have not voteed yet this year but will start in a week or so when it gets down to about 5 left. When I do vote I usually get in around 100 votes or more before I stop dialing.

If you don't get your votes in, then???

[MSgt]

So David Cook is the only non-experienced dude in there now? Or am I forgetting someone else?

If that is accurate we should all vote for him. I have never voted but I would in this case - just as a protest.

[EDH Jen]

So how many of you people actually vote??? I have not voteed yet this year but will start in a week or so when it gets down to about 5 left. When I do vote I usually get in around 100 votes or more before I stop dialing.

If you don't get your votes in, then???

I have never once voted, although I remember wanting to vote for Reuben.