229 replies to this topic

[kanda]

I still think that American Idol should have the fans vote for the worst singer each week.

Believe me, I share your frustration. But I don't think that would work any better. Then you'd have groups thinking it'd be funny to vote off the best singer instead of those who think it's funny to keep around the worst.

I think someone else suggested that America should pick the bottom 2 or 3, and then the judges should decide out of that group who should go home. That might work better. But since Sanjaya has yet to be in the bottom 2 or 3, it's obviously still not perfect.

I'm another Jordin & Melinda fan. I think they're both great, and would be happy to see either of them win. I'd give the nod to Jordin if I could, since she hasn't had the years of experience Melinda has, and yet she's still fantastic.

[folsombound]

I think Sanjaya should win it all, thus sending this show to the netherworld where it belongs!

[mylo]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

[camay2327]

Glad he is gone...

[johncam]

I think Sanjaya should win it all, thus sending this show to the netherworld where it belongs!

Hehe. You know what -- he just might! What will it matter though? Whether you win or not, making the top 10 or so, coupled with whether you have real talent, etc., is enough to launch a successful career (Daughtrey and unfortunately, Clay). Ergo, we'll all forget about Sanjaya a few months from now.

[Jolene]

Wahoo!!

[cw68]

Perhaps there is a God afterall.

[MikeinFolsom]

Me thinks all of the college supporters he has benefited from in the past were pre-occupied by the events that unfolded at VT and they forgot to vote?? Anyways.....what the heck was Blake doing in the bottom 3? My wife thinks he's batting on the other side of the plate.....hmmmmm.

[MSgt]

going... going... GONE!!!! YAHOO!!

[nj78]

I think the show has finally jumped the shark. Sanjaya gone = boring show.

[Jenncez]

Perhaps there is a God afterall.

Took the words right out of my mouth! I'm so happy to see him go. Now it's a real competition!! WOOHOOO

[mylo]

Took the words right out of my mouth! I'm so happy to see him go. Now it's a real competition!! WOOHOOO

No it's not. Now it's a boring show with an obvious winner.

It was actually worth watching with Sanjaya in the running!

[nj78]

That's what I meant.

[mylo]

Finally, Sanjaya to get the recognition he truly deserves:

Sanjaya to Dine With President Bush

[tessieca]

How ridiculous! Did you see the Sanjaya-like clip on Daily Show? Sr. Legal Analyst was supposed to reporting on the Supreme Court's abortion decision, but were in Hollywood with Sanjaya's weirdest hairstyle (you know the one!). Funny. At least they understand that he's the object of ridicule and not someone who should be attending a correspondent's dinner.