381 replies to this topic

[hopeanelli]

LOL Simon!
I agree though.

Me too but I still think he is better than Kristi Lee when you do a look at performances so far she sucked last week and this week. And I would have removed Amanda for sure before him. I loved Amanda the first few times ( I am a Janis Joplin Grace Slick fan) but I don't think she will be able to tame that voice and do a Ballad or a Poppy song... Oh Well I will get over it eventually today...I have to it's lunch time and I am still whiny about it.....

[brown]

Too bad, he was definitely the least sucky of the bottom 3. It was just an off week for him.

[cw68]

Eww, he just creeped me out and it's not because he was a male dancer. I kinda like male dancers. Remember the other night when he was out on the cat walk and as he was coming back to the stage twirling around close to the crowd with that look in his eye? The guy was just working it way too hard. I found it painful to watch his antics and then I couldn't get into the song, even though his voice rocks. There was no believability factor, just cheese.

Amanda is totally hot and cold to me. Half of me is irritated by her and her get-ups, but then if I stop looking at her and listen, she can blow the top off a song.

[hopeanelli]

Ok so last nights show was disappointing to me for some reason, not sure if it's because it was the Beatles again (which I love) but last week was so good it was hard to compare.. I don't know I just didn't like the same kind of music two weeks in a row. I think they should have more current music so we can see how they will do with today's music anyways my opinion...

So here is how I graded them on a scale of 1 to 10 -- 10 being the best... If anyone else wants let me know how you would have scored them. A fun little weekly thing I do and see how close we are when the vote off comes tonight..

Amanda - 6
Kristi Lee - 5
David A- 10,10,10 he was awesome
Micheal - 6 he doesn't belong on AMERICAN IDOL
Brooke - 8
David Cook - 10++ love him
Carly - 7 she too doesn't belong on AMERICAN IDOL
Chickezee - 8
Seyesha - 7
Ramielle - 7
Jason - 7

I think tonight Kristi Lee,Amanda and Ramielle will be in the lowest 3.. While Micheal wasn't great America likes him...same with Jason he will survive I think ..

Amanda would be good if it was just Girl Rocker Idol I think her attitude is a little over confident not sure if she will make it tonight..

[brown]

Ok so last nights show was disappointing to me for some reason, not sure if it's because it was the Beatles again (which I love) but last week was so good it was hard to compare.. I don't know I just didn't like the same kind of music two weeks in a row. I think they should have more current music so we can see how they will do with today's music anyways my opinion...

So here is how I graded them on a scale of 1 to 10 -- 10 being the best... If anyone else wants let me know how you would have scored them. A fun little weekly thing I do and see how close we are when the vote off comes tonight..

Amanda - 6
Kristi Lee - 5
David A- 10,10,10 he was awesome
Micheal - 6 he doesn't belong on AMERICAN IDOL
Brooke - 8
David Cook - 10++ love him
Carly - 7 she too doesn't belong on AMERICAN IDOL
Chickezee - 8
Seyesha - 7
Ramielle - 7
Jason - 7

I think tonight Kristi Lee,Amanda and Ramielle will be in the lowest 3.. While Micheal wasn't great America likes him...same with Jason he will survive I think ..

Amanda would be good if it was just Girl Rocker Idol I think her attitude is a little over confident not sure if she will make it tonight..

The 2 David's were good, the rest stunk. My cats got all puffy when Amanda was singing.

[Jenncez]

Amanda - 6
Kristi Lee - 5
David A- 10,10,10 he was awesome
Micheal - 6 he doesn't belong on AMERICAN IDOL
Brooke - 8
David Cook - 10++ love him
Carly - 7 she too doesn't belong on AMERICAN IDOL
Chickezee - 8
Seyesha - 7
Ramielle - 7
Jason - 7

My scores...

Amanda - 4
Kristi Lee - 8
David A - 9
Michael - 8
Brooke - 8 (I LOVED her last week...she looked awkward last night)
David C - 10
Carly - 6
Chikeze - 10
Seyesha - 8
Ramielle - 6
Jason - 9

Amanda needs to go...she doesn't fit in. Her and Ramielle should be in the bottom 2. I'm sure Amanda won't be and Kristi will, but Kristi was a LOT better than her. Oh well. I didn't vote so I can't complain.

[camay2327]

Kicked off tonight... Spoiler....

















Look below












Amanda Overmyer, 23 from Mulberry, Indiana

[Steve Heard]

They got it right! She was one-dimensional, and that one dimension was terrible.

[MSgt]

They got it right! She was one-dimensional, and that one dimension was terrible.

scary rocker chick gone - no suprise. She didn't seem suprised. I was suprised to see Carly in the bottom 3.

[brown]

Well, they got that one right.

[Jenncez]

Yay for America picking the right person to be kicked off!

[Darthvader]

Yay for America picking the right person to be kicked off!

They should have booted that other girl off as well, Kristy Lee Cook. She has been horrible the last 3 weeks but she has skirted by. I'm SURE she'll be gone next week but it seems silly to drag it out when it's obvious who the least talented are of the group that remains.

[hopeanelli]

It was time for Amanda to go in the beginning her rocker voice was cool but it's the same thing week after week and she has a nasty little smug attitude. If you noticed any of her interactions with the other girls she was always very distant not very huggy lovely, or at least friendly with them (maybe she plays for the the other team) not sure but glad she is gone although Kristi Lee should have been gone last week...

On to next week...

[EDH Jen]

On to next week...

I haven't been watching for the past two weeks, since hearing people mutilate Beatles music is more than I can bear (to quote Joel McHale from The Soup, "Congratulations Yoko Ono, assasins, and one-legged gold-diggers. You are no longer the worst thing to ever happen to the Beatles!") so I'm looking forward to next week, as well.

[hopeanelli]

I haven't been watching for the past two weeks, since hearing people mutilate Beatles music is more than I can bear (to quote Joel McHale from The Soup, "Congratulations Yoko Ono, assasins, and one-legged gold-diggers. You are no longer the worst thing to ever happen to the Beatles!") so I'm looking forward to next week, as well.

Ahh love Joel McHale- couldn't have said it better myself.. One week of Beatles was perfect two was over the top..

Next week better be Country or Kristi Lee Cook will be gone.. I loved Kelly Pickler last night she is so cute...