Who decided to end it, and why? I thought Sutter Street was being revitalized to help support more events like TNM? This is a let down to hear it's being discontinued.
TNM was a merchant's association (FHDA) event. not only did it lose money every year, it was actually becoming dangerous. there were fights and vandalism just about every week. FHDA had hired a paid event planner to run the TNM for three years. no matter how it was changed (fewer vendors, more food, less food, etc) people did not come to support it. the biggest problem was the masses of kids who came (many dropped off by the parents and picked up after the event). while most kids were fine, they grouped together and vendors were turned off by it. no one bought anything so the vendors wouldn't commit to a whole summer of thursdays. the kids and thugs who stayed off in the shadows created issues too. they staged big fights on side streets and created trouble for the neighborhoods and the merchants in the Lakes center. no matter how much security was added, the trouble makers seemed to know how to avoid it.
FHDA tried very hard to make TNM work. the plan now is to try to come up with fewer, but better, events that bring a better mix of visitors in. Second Saturday is a prime example of that.
Knowing the past helps deciphering the future.